I've never shot a pistol caliber lever rifle, but in revolvers every now and then I have gotten a split case useing aluminum cases. ase walls are fairly thin, and Aluminum is fairly soft, any kind of flaw in the metal gives you a higher chance of a split case than with brass, But aluminum is less expensive to work and generally non reloadable so while you pay less per box when you are done you have to buy another box, there by increasing their sales.