Tom,
Appreciate your comments. But in my book a retired Command Sgt Major has earned the right to judge who is a good soldier or marine. That my friend is his job. He in fact does have the authority and responsibility to make that kind of call whether he is a marine NCO or not. Check it out in UCMJ.
But if you marines want to claim Murtha be my guest. That said, I do absolutely support the mantra of "once a marine, always a marine." That goes for soldiers, airmen and sailors as well. We are all on the same side.
You have NO IDEA how much it P!$$es me off to have to defend that slanderous turd murtha ! But once a Marine has completed boot camp, Parris Island OR San Diego, NO ONE has the right to tell him he is no Marine, It does not matter if it is an Army General or a Marine General. If the President told someone "You are no Marine" the Pres would be told to go F himself, And that Marines Superiors would back him up. If you don't believe me ask at
www.grunt.com It is however perfectly acceptable to say "He's a disgrace to the Corps","He takes Arab bribes" "He's a sniveling rat"" He's a Party hack who would kiss every butt in the state to get re elected", "He's a liar", It's even acceptable , (and true) to say he is being sued by the Marines wrongly accused in Haditha.
But regardless of what a shit bird he has become we have to accept him just like Lee Harvey Oswald and Charles Whitman. Once a Marine always a Marine, wether the rest of the Marines like it or not
Ron, I hope the shock was not to much for your system
PS. Be advised that this IS NOT a rant, It is simply an educational comment about "Traditions of The Corps" a reminder that like Judas, no matter what depths he has sunk to now , once LONG ago, he was worthy.