If we had invaded Iraq for oil I'd have been all for it. Instead we invaded it for bugger all. We replaced one anti American regime with another. In Afghanistan what are we fighting over? There's nothing there but fanatics and rocks. The only thing they can agree on is that they hate us more than each other. Trying to civilize these people is like trying to teach a donkey to sing. The day after we leave they'll go right back to killing each other once we're out of the way. A liberal will say this view makes me a racist. A conservative will say I'm a defeatist. I say I'm a freaking realist. You want to stay there? What's your plan?
As some one who thinks the Taliban are fighting our war for us I just think you're an idiot.
But you probably knew that already.

What US troops are fighting for in Afghanistan is some never defined "victory".
What Obama's "Surge" from the special ops and training of the Bush years to the full scale quagmire is intended to do is to bring a free people under control of a socialist regime with out the 100 of preparation that the US and England required.
The Afghan tribesman has his religion, his rifle and a subsistence crop to feed his family.
He never wanted any thing more, he never needed anything more, and he never asked for anything more.
US troops are being used for the evil purpose of suppressing that same spirit that you members here bemoan the loss of in our own country.
The Taliban are better Americans than we are because they have guts enough to fight for their freedom.
Americans on the other hand voted it away for a cell phone and BS.
Even the Egyptians, who have lived under Dictators for about 4,000 years are more serious about their rights than complacent, lazy, ARMED Americans.
http://news.yahoo.com/100-000-protest-egypts-presidential-palace-232530692.htmlCAIRO (AP) — More than 100,000 Egyptians protested outside the presidential palace in Cairo on Tuesday, fueling tensions over Islamist leader Mohammed Morsi's seizure of nearly unrestricted powers and the adoption by his allies of a controversial draft constitution.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>MORE AT LINK<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<