"Back in 07", I bought a Taurus 85 for somewhere around $300 and the grip fell apart at 50 rounds.
I replaced it with a S&W, 360 PD, for just north of a Thousand, I think, and the firing pin broke on the 13th round..
This was for the (now late) wife, and she wouldn't touch either one after the failures occurred. I ended up finding a Security Six, "UNFIRED!" for just under $500 (ish) and it never gave either one of us a single problem.
As wheel guns go, I picked up an indiscretion for my birthday, (at link
http://www.smith-wesson.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/Product4_750001_750051_766309_-1____ProductDisplayErrorView_Y ) and while it's not as accurate as I would like, it sure is pretty!!!
I still really want a GP 100 357 with a 3" barrel and the old style wood insert grips.
After that, I'd also really like a S&W 327 (357 Mag). I believe this one would serve your purposes, but MSRP is 1,300. The best I see on Gunbroker is around 1,100 new and just under a Grand, used.
-----
Ever have something like a band that you like, that if you admitted it, you'd be ridiculed into the next county?
I want about 10 of those NAA "Sidewinder" 22 Mag rigs, with the built in holster that flips over like a pocket knife! (2 per car and two each for wife and I..)

But I'm not really into wheel guns.....
Oh, forgot my favorite.. It's a 325 PD Custom Shop thing, (discontinued, of course). It might also work well in this situation. 45 acp/moon clips. Very easy/light shooter. If you can find one, it's worthy of your consideration. I promise!