For the size targets and distances your mentioning + hunting, I'm real fond of my Leupold 3.5X10 MK4 - M3 illuminated, I have the mil-dot, but for what your doing it would not be necessary, and you really would not need the M3 version, an M1 would work with a duplex reticle. You can get basically the same set up in the lower cost LRT model, not milspec. see riflescopes.com for a close up look at all of them.
Here's a pic of mine, not real good, but it is not an overly large scope.
