In smaller calibers, I have read many finicky reviews of Charter Arms, if someone has some others great. However their larger caliber Bulldog, and other 44's seem to have a loyal following. Must be something there, at least on the larger calibers.
Did you try different varieties of ammo with the same result?
Glad you were not seriously injured, and the pistol was at least not damaged to the point of non-returnable....Good call on the LCR.
Welcome to DRTV.