Gander Mountain is evil. They keep having sales! >:(I was strong enough to walk away from the $1K Armalite AR-10 largely because I can't afford it, but still, I walked away.

I did not, however manage to make it past the Surefire or Gerber cases. As it is still daylight, I cannot give a range report on the 6P other than to say that its built like a tank and for $60 on sale it was too good to pass up. ( UPDATE: the ambiguous range report is in a following post).
The Gerber, I am really excited about. I have wanted a Leatherman style tool for years, but couldn't find one that had the tools I wanted at the right price and quality. This one wins. I got the "Suspension Multiplier". Its actually about their cheapest one, but thats not why I chose it. Its small, about three and one half inches folded. It also has some spring tension on the pliers and a pair of scissors. Perfect! Its aluminum (titanium coated) construction with windows cut out so water and sand should pass through. It feels heavy and solid in the hand. Other than an asinine "saw" (for very leeeetle trees

) there is nothing there I won't use. Two screw drivers, a straight blade, a serrated knife, can opener/bottle opener, lanyard anchor, "saw", and scissors. The wire cutters in the pliers are pretty solid (though not ideal) as well. Basically I'd rate them good enough for off shore fishing, not good enough for an electrician. Its also a lockblade. The only downside is the switch to unlock the blade is a ittle small and took a shot of Rem Lube to get working without brute force. Once it was lubed, its perfect. All in all it was the best $32 I've spent in a while.
FQ13 who has mixed feelings about the Surefire, but loves the Gerber