I sent this as a PM originally, but thought I'd post it. As a pretty serious bird dog guy, I thought I'd promote an FDSB Chessie or an FDSB or NAVDA Drathaar. Still, the post might be of general interest, and might sitr some controversy as I am all in favor of buying from a reputable breeder and have little use for "pound puppies". That's just my thing, YMMV. Anyway, here's the post.
FQ13
To:
Huntnelk
If you want a good retriever, I can't reccomend a Chessie enough. I'm a pointer guy myself. I prefer quail to ducks (though I do like duck hunting), but living in Florida? If you use a retriever, you better not get too attached to it, as the gators love their dogs.

Still, a chessie is a great breed. They are more athletic than a lab and a whole lot "sharper", and a lot more stubborn. They are not fluffy bunnies. Buying a chessie is like buying a gun. They are smart and affectionate and damn good at what they do. They will kick a lab's ass in cold water (like you have in Wyoming) every day of the week. That said, they will bite and need serious discipline and training, and here I'm talking the "Dog Whisperer" not Michael Vick.
Just understand, they are not a dog you buy and ignore. Buy it young, train it well, and work with it daily and you're good. Fail to do that? Its your own damn fault. I would highly recoomend Field Dog Stud Book dogs over the AKC. AKC dogs are breed for confirmation. FDSB dogs are bred for performance. They will cost close to a grand. But that thousand bucks will be the least amount of money you ever spend on the dog when you factor in vet bills, dogfood, chew toys etc.. The Quaker's opinion is that it's as easy to love a good dog as a bad one. Rescue dogs are nice in theory. Real life? Why not give youself the best chance for success you can? Buy once and buy right. I'd start with the "American Field" and "Gun Dog Digest". The breeders who advertise are generally solid. Even if they don't breed your type of dog, they probably know someone who does. The serious bird dog world is pretty small. Most breeders know each other and frauds don't last long.
FQ13
PS if you do upland hunting as well, Draathars, or German wire haired pointers, would fit the bill as well. If you can't hit the bird, the dog can always just ugly them to death.

Plus, they are good for ducks and will cheerfully eat your ass. They are just terminally goofy, but still good hunters, good pets and not what a thief wants to run into.
Here's the address of "American Field". You won't find it in store's and you are cheating youself if you don't subscribe and use it to find a good breeder. No BS, the 6 month subscrition is the best money you'll spend, as you will get in touch with some very serious folks who will be happy to give you advice. Their advertisers are the real deal, and most don't care if you buy their dogs or not. You might find yourself on a waiting list. A man with more business than he can handle is an honest man, simply because he doesn't need your money and thus has no reason to lie. Buy the mag, make the calls, and engage these guys in conversation. You'll learn a lot if you are patient, and you'll probably find a good pup as well. Just sayin' that the hours I've spent chatting these guys up haven't been wasted.
http://www.americanfield.com/