Street Justice In The Bronx...Thoughts on Intervention?

[tombogan03884]

FQ exhibits his usual lack of reading comprehension.    

This was NY, Honest people in NY can't carry guns.  Even if he had a CCW  it doesn't make him a cop, since he was in no danger, he was not justified in shooting, since the article says "Detectives questioned the woman, who is the mother of Williams' 3-year-old son, at the 40th Precinct stationhouse." and makes no mention of hospital she apparently was also not "in imminent danger" so the defense of others is also not a valid defense for this gang banger to butt in and murder the guy.

[fightingquaker13]

I read just fine Tom, even between the lines. Given the facts in the OP, all I can say is that karma can be a bitch and the prosecutor wouldn't want me on that jury, as the length of deliberations would be measured by the quality of the coffee.
FQ13

[tombogan03884]

I read just fine Tom, even between the lines. Given the facts in the OP, all I can say is that karma can be a bitch and the prosecutor wouldn't want me on that jury, as the length of deliberations would be measured by the quality of the coffee.
FQ13

 

And the cops who let him go ten times before are to be respected why? Sorry Tom, it comes down to this. In a perfect world, the police would protect us and I wouldn't need to pack a Glock. However, they don't and I do. If in an extreme case like this, where a guy takes matters into his own hands? Well, I don't condone it, as if you let that slip too many times you wake up in Somalia, but just once? I see nothing, I hear nothing and I know nothing, and I won't lose sleep over it either.
FQ13

This is one example of your stupidity, You live in a state that allows you to carry a Glock. This incident did not happen in Fl. it happened in NY city, where under most circumstances such conduct is the sort of crime that all of you should be jumping all over with the usual sniveling about "ammunition for the anti's".  Remember how you all rant when the anti's talk about "Vigilante justice".
For all you people know the bitch may have needed a tune up.

[TAB]

I don't know about NY, but in CA, you can use deadly force to protect some one else.

[fightingquaker13]

This is one example of your stupidity, You live in a state that allows you to carry a Glock. This incident did not happen in Fl. it happened in NY city, where under most circumstances such conduct is the sort of crime that all of you should be jumping all over with the usual sniveling about "ammunition for the anti's".  Remember how you all rant when the anti's talk about "Vigilante justice".
For all you people know the bitch may have needed a tune up.

Tom, think before posting. You don't hit a girl.Period! Its kind of the whole being a man not a punk thing... No one needs a "tune up".
FQ13

[Sponsor]

[tombogan03884]

Tom, think before posting. You don't hit a girl.Period! Its kind of the whole being a man not a punk thing... No one needs a "tune up".
FQ13

Posted by a college know it all who's never been married.

TAB, based on the story it does not seem that she was in danger of major injury or death.

[TAB]

Posted by a college know it all who's never been married.

TAB, based on the story it does not seem that she was in danger of major injury or death.

from the sound of it she was, maybe not right then, but it was bound to happen.

[fightingquaker13]

Posted by a college know it all who's never been married.

 

Never been divorced, and never raised my hand to a woman either. As for the "tune up" I'll send you to M'lette. Not a a fan of the B word either, but maybe its a Southern thing. You don't hit a girl and you don't use that word in that context if you're a gentleman, end of story. College has nothing to do with it, its a lot deeper than that.
FQ13

[tombogan03884]

I never claimed to be a gentleman. As for hitting women I believe if I had knocked my ex on her ass once or twice I would probably still be married.
As for my choice of language, I don't care if it offends. I'm not a college graduate, I say what I mean in unmistakable language. I even call a "spade" a " f*cking shovel".

[kmitch200]

tom wrote:
This was NY, Honest people in NY can't carry guns.

I have to disagree. There are permits issued in NY. A bunch of hoops to jump through yes, but they can be obtained.

Even if he had a CCW  it doesn't make him a cop, since he was in no danger, he was not justified in shooting, since the article says "Detectives questioned the woman, who is the mother of Williams' 3-year-old son, at the 40th Precinct stationhouse." and makes no mention of hospital she apparently was also not "in imminent danger" so the defense of others is also not a valid defense for this gang banger to butt in and murder the guy.

I can only answer in the context of AZ laws, not being versed in NY law. 
That said, protection of a 3rd party is entirely justifiable, and we in AZ have no "duty to warn."

The disparity of force between a woman and a man beating on her is obvious and places her in a definite catagory of imminent danger, just like getting attacked by 2 or more asshats would place us in the same boat.
No mention of a hospital could mean the assault was stopped in time for her not to need a hospital - another few seconds and it could have been much different. A head bounced off a sidewalk can be fatal

For all you people know the bitch may have needed a tune up.

I have been divorced 3 times. None of which ended up with me "giving the bitch a tune up", not that the thought didn't cross my mind.
Besides the fact I wasn't raised that way, you don't get to own a gun if you do. (Lautenberg)

There is no mention of any gangbanger being involved. Living in a crap area doesn't make you automatically a gangbanger.
I hope the guy is able to keep his mouth shut - by leaving, the legal system will crucify him.