I would reserve judgement to a certain extent.
Yes, the Statie was a dumbass for misidentifying his target, however I have observed that non hunters are darned irresponsible about what they wear in the woods during hunting season.
Some half wit wearing a brown coat gets shot and the first reaction is to blame the hunter (wearing blaze orange) for being careless.
True but any hunter that I would trust would never take a shot in fading light, after sunset, knowing full well that there may be folks out in the woods. Norton ain't exactly the most rural of places to live. As I said, the law says you MUST be out of the hunting area 1/2 hour after sunset. The sun set Dec. 31 at 4:21. This guy should have already stopped hunting for the day! Being a cop doesn't mean he should not have to read the hunting regs like everyone else!
These are the reasons I only hunt with a very, very small group of people I trust.
Another thing to note is that the womans husband is an avid hunter and teaches Hunter Education which is required by state law. The woman may have assumed that since it was after sunset she was good to take the dogs for a walk.
Not saying that's the case but it's possible!