Pincus's March Madness

[JovanS]

Take a look if nothing else should be interesting to see all of the different views.

http://www.downrange.tv/blog/march-madness-for-defensive-firearms/13801/

....Really Rob?!?! An LCP vs. the Judge talk about a David vs. Goliath matchup 

[ronlarimer]

I had some fun with it and did a 3 part series on my blog... http://www.balloongoesup.com/blog/2012/03/march-madness-for-defensive-firearms/

[jnevis]

I let Larry Potterfield do all the work

The Defensive Handgun ads he does has most of them already matched or a close variation; XD9 for XDM9, Colt Defender for the Kimber, or P226 in 40 but used the "Knock down factor" for the 9.  Those he doesn't I took the closest type and caliber SW342 with 45ACP for the Judge, G19 for the Caracal.

Since the 226 and 239 would be effectively equal with his criteria I gave it to the 239 for better concealability.

In the end it was the TRP (1911) and MP45 with the M&P just edging it out due to capacity.

[Hazcat]

Missing a LOT of good guns, Subbies in .357/38, tried and true TOKs, Bursa Thunders, Sigs, Walther PPKs.  All in all a stupid match up.  Just what I would expect considering the source.

[ronlarimer]

Missing a LOT of good guns, Subbies in .357/38, tried and true TOKs, Bursa Thunders, Sigs, Walther PPKs.  All in all a stupid match up.  Just what I would expect considering the source.

There was a subby, 2 Sigs, and a pm9 for the a little too big to pocket category. I figure this was thrown together and covered most modern carry categories in standard guns.

I think your being a bit rough and letting some obvious bias against Rob keep you from missing the point.


NC Buckeye

[Sponsor]