Personally, I don't think it makes a dimes worth of difference. Unless you're into three gun competion, we're talking across the living room with 'OO buck shot. Any stock will do. Get whatever feels comfortable. For hunting, I prefer a straight stock on a SxS. For HD, whatever works. I have a semi pistol grip on my maverick riot gun and I don't plan on changing it. I mean honestly, how often are you going to shoot the thing? For me, I patterned it, satisfied myself that it will go bang, and that's probably the last time it will be fired unless I need it. Its a freaking riot gun. No riot (or burglar) I have no use for it. Don't stress over this. Just buy whatever makes you happy. If you are going to shoot skeet or hunt, my answer will differ.