Unless you have the fucked up skank full retard refugee from a hippy commune bitch that I have for a mail carrier!!!
I think this is basically it in a nutshell. All of this with all 3 outfits depends on the driver, along with the route you have. After all, when you break it down they're all
delivery services that hire
delivery men. In that regard they're no different than Domino's. For everyone who uses these services, they're no better / worse than the guy or gal driving the truck. Even though both bad experiences I had didn't involve drivers.
The first was with Natchez involving UPS. It was a case of .45 ACP Blazer Brass. It came late, repackaged, (Natchez's package had gotten broken open, and looked like the package Tom Hanks finally delivered 4 years later in "Castaway"). There were loose rounds rolling around inside. And I was missing 2 boxes with around 11 rounds missing out of the third box. I called Natchez, and they immediately apologized and sent out 5 more boxes which more than made it right. All based on my word alone. I don't know if UPS contacted them about the damage or not. I rather doubt it because they never mentioned it to me, and seemed rather surprised by the whole thing.
The second time was again with Natchez and UPS. I ordered 16 pounds of powder. (Accurate 2230-C). It was a canister powder they had a really good price on. (Just $64.00 for a 8 pound jug). The delivery time came and went. Nothing changed on UPS's website. It just kept showing, "Out For Delivery". After several days, (4 or 5), I called Natchez. While I was on the phone making arrangements for another order, UPS showed up. The package was in perfect condition, but no explanation was given.
Other than that I've never had any trouble with any of the three. UPS, Fed Ex, USPS. Of the 3 I like USPS the best. For me anyway, they're the cheapest and the fastest. Especially on stuff like Hornady 6,000 round boxes of bulk bullets, and other heavy stuff.