And finally....................
IT'S DONE! The plumbing supply store called me yesterday morning and told me my 10" rough in toilet had arrived. So I went and picked it up. An hour later the plumber stopped by and installed it. It fit perfectly. So... 8 long days after this fiasco started, it's all finally finished. Both bathrooms really look nice. New tile floors, and both with nice new toilets, supply lines, and valves.... This is what I learned from all of this, that may help you guys who are ever going to attempt bathroom improvements:
Helpful Hint #1.) Always measure your toilet drain from the wall to centerline of the pipe,
immediately after removing your old toilet, and before ordering any new ones. You, like me, may require a 10" rough in toilet.
Helpful Hint #2.) Always buy the extra tall wax sealing ring with the rubber flange poured into it. They're just a couple of bucks more, and seal much better.
THIS IS WHAT YOU WANT:https://www.ebarnett.com/Sku/191170?CID=Shop_Barnett_THD500_PP_1_ALL_C&CAWELAID=120259710000003141&CAGPSPN=pla&CAAGID=27472108846&CATCI=pla-174369358846&gclid=Cj0KEQjw-YO7BRDwi6Stp7T296ABEiQAD6iWMSgaMrafCCNU_8RDPO6N4NACtiO-dV9TUkUH8cU4yxQaAmR_8P8HAQNOT THIS:http://www.supplyhouse.com/Hercules-90210-Johni-Ring-Wax-Toilet-Gasket-Waste-Lines-Standard-Size-for-3-or-4-Waste-Lines?gclid=Cj0KEQjw-YO7BRDwi6Stp7T296ABEiQAD6iWMfMs2Lp2Gp65-hCmKGBcjHR7kFNQd_s-BaMQi7T_IgwaAmF28P8HAQHelpful Hint #3). Buy a pair of
SHORT toilet mounting bolts. The ones they give you with the toilet are usually way too tall, because they don't know what kind of flooring situation you have going on. 99% of the time the studs will be too long, and the caps won't sit right. They'll spin around on the top of the studs and look stupid. If you can't find short studs, you need to go with tall caps, which are not easy to find, let alone find them in colors, (I needed Almond or Biscuit color).
You don't want to have to cut off the bolts because they're a PITA to get to, and you'll have limited access to cut them off without getting a charley horse. And it's very easy to scratch up your nice, brand new toilet. So it's tall caps or short bolts. Measure beforehand and see what you'll need. And buy them in
Stainless Steel, not brass. Many times the bolts look to be made of solid brass. But most are just brass plated, and will easily corrode over time. Go by price. Stainless Steel bolts will cost over triple what the brass plated one's sell for.
Helpful Hint #4). No matter how nice or expensive of a toilet you buy, it's all but guaranteed they'll package it with the most cheap $h!t, plastic toilet seat they can possibly find. Every aftermarket toilet seat I've ever purchased, regardless of price, will slide around on the top of the bowl. This regardless of how much you try to tighten the cheap plastic bolts all are provided with.
I finally found a solution. Buy a Bemis "Slow Close / Stay Tight" toilet seat. They're $40.00, but are worth every penny.
They have a patented bolt system that centers the bolt at both the top and the bottom, in the oversize porcelain holes all toilets have. The nuts they give you with it are almost 2" inches long. And are easy to tighten when you're working all but upside down, trying at the same time to get a wrench on them. After you snug them up,
the seat will NOT slide around. And they stay tight. As the name say's, they have a nice hinge system, that gently closes both the seat and the lid so they'll never slam down on the bowl. This is the seat. They come in both round and elongated, in most any color. Both of mine match perfectly.
http://www.homedepot.com/p/BEMIS-Slow-Close-STA-TITE-Elongated-Closed-Front-Toilet-Seat-in-Bone-1201SLOW-006/205003588Let's face it. We're all men here. And there are some things in a man's life that we want to go smoothly. Taking a crap is one of them. What I've outlined here will help assure that for generations to come.