Here's a question:
"If a bullet expands and penetrates 6" and another bullet does not expand, but penetrates 12", which one does more damage?"
No simple answer to that one. Depends on shot placement, most of all, and all the variables involved with such. IMHO.
Divide the torso into four sections. Two upper and two lower. Shoot a 400 pound man in the lower left quadrant of the torso and you would not expect the same damage to vitals as in any of the other three. Either might stop him, but either might not. But the liver is on the right and would stand a better chance of massive bleed out with the expanding round.
I posted months ago about a guy I used to work with getting shot in the pectoral muscle with a wadcutter from a snubby .38.
He was a big, somewhat muscular fellow, and the slug stopped a couple of inches into the muscle itself. He then took the gun away from the shooter and beat hell out of him with it. Better load might have ended differently, OR different shot placement with same load might have ended differently also.
Man, too many variables in life.
