I have, at one time or another, had subscriptions to every gun magazine in existance. Believe me...every single one.
Frankly, the only magazines I continue to renew my subscription to are:
Guns
American Handgunner
Small Arms Review
American Rifleman -- part of my Life Endowment NRA membership
American's First Freedom -- my "gift" to the NRA
I like Guns and American Handgunner because they are irreverent and I feel they are more objective than most. I also think they've got the best line up of writers. Connor, Taffin, Venturino, Bodison, Smith, etc.