A 2LT. or a Captain with an idea or a compass are the most deadly things I have dealt with. Thank God the Lt. I worked for was a former NCO and he let me run the whole show in Iraq. His job was to keep the good idea fairy (Captain) out of my hair and smoke screen him until I got the job done. He even kept the idiot 1SG. we had out of my hair most of the time. These two idiots wanted me to give two E-5s that are the worst NCOs I have ever met excellent ratings on their NCOER evaluations. Even after I showed them all the negative counseling statements and the poor performance incidents the 1SG still wanted me to give them excellent ratings. I advised the Captain that some of the stuff they did they should be reduced in rank over. He finally agreed with me and told the 1SG. to let it go. The 1SG and I still do not get along and I will be glad to go back to my old unit. So much for trying to fix a messed up unit.