Depends. Its just my experience, but here is what I look for in a scope. Clarity, click adjustment, light gathering ability, waterproof/fog proof and price. I don't care much about aesthetics or weight. I'd rather have a larger scope that will let me use it at dusk or on a dim range rather than your "dainty" thing that looks cool but makes me squint. If rimfire means I save a buck or two because it isn't built to take heavy recoil that's fine. If it means a smaller objective lens I'd pass. Also, I've not tried one, but they seem nice for the money and come recommended, are the Cabela's house brand Alaskan Guide series. Please keep us updated, as my eyes are getting to the point where I need an optic on my 10/22 and I'm dithering between a red dot and glass.