Erik, I do agree with your article, when I was match director for our local tactical pistol matches, there would always be one distance stage, 1-3 shots at 50 plus yards, usually steel but not always. I caught a lot of flak for it, and it even made a thread here. Not only does it hone your skill, but should also show your limitations, you should know where your ability ends. Now that my eyes are older, those shots are hard to make with confidence with irons.
Your scenario is one good example. The one I use, is your at the lake in your boat, waiting at the ramp for your wife to back the truck and trailer up, you watch as your wife gets to the truck, and 2 men approach her, how far is that, could be a hundred yards.
What choice do you have if their intentions are malicious? Hopefully her pistol is ready!