I absolutely LOVE the Camaro....my first car was a 67. I got a chance to sit in a new one at a car show here recently. Sadly though, the new Camaro doesn't fit me. I am too tall at 6'4" to sit in it comfortably. I'd give hard eyeball to a convertible, but the coupe is a no-go for me.
The Challenger, which I was able to drive for a weekend a couple of months ago because a friend who recently purchased one borrowed my Tahoe left me his Challenger to drive...was a fantastic ride. It had loads of power, handled well, and was comfortable even for my frame. It really reminded me of the 70's R/T.
My last pickup was a 2002 Dodge 1500. I would still have it had some knucklehead not t-boned me after running a stop light in 2007. It was my 2nd Dodge, and I was totally happy with both trucks. Dodge customer service was great, and dealership support was really good too. I can't imagine it would be otherwise with a Challenger.
I would have purchased another Dodge, had I been looking for a pickup again. I only went with the Tahoe because I wanted a full-size SUV and the Durango wasn't as large as I wanted. Now that I have had the new Tahoe for 2 years, I won't buy anything else.
What I am saying is: I'd buy the Challenger. Looks good, drives great, has a metric shitload of power and eye appeal, and it fits me.